The diagnostic system : why the classification of psychiatric disorders is necessary, difficult, and never settled / Jason Schnittker.

Author
Schnittker, Jason [Browse]
Format
Book
Language
English
Published/​Created
New York : Columbia University Press, [2017]
Description
viii, 348 pages : illustrations ; 24 cm

Availability

Available Online

Copies in the Library

Location Call Number Status Location Service Notes
Firestone Library - Stacks RC469 .S36 2017 Browse related items Request

    Details

    Subject(s)
    Summary note
    Mental illness is many things at once: It is a natural phenomenon that is also shaped by society and culture. It is biological but also behavioral and social. Mental illness is a problem of both the brain and the mind, and this ambiguity presents a challenge for those who seek to accurately classify psychiatric disorders. The leading resource we have for doing so is the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, but no edition of the manual has provided a decisive solution, and all have created controversy. In The Diagnostic System, the sociologist Jason Schnittker looks at the multiple actors involved in crafting the DSM and the many interests that the manual hopes to serve. Is the DSM the best tool for defining mental illness? Can we insure against a misleading approach? Schnittker shows that the classification of psychiatric disorders is best understood within the context of a system that involves diverse parties with differing interests. The public wants a better understanding of personal suffering. Mental-health professionals seek reliable and treatable diagnostic categories. Scientists want definitions that correspond as closely as possible to nature. Everyone seeks definitive insight into what they regard as the right target. Yet even the best classification system cannot satisfy all of these interests simultaneously. Progress toward an ideal is difficult, and revisions to diagnostic criteria often serve the interests of one group at the expense of another.
    Bibliographic references
    Includes bibliographical references (pages 307-331) and index.
    Contents
    • The deep ambiguity of mental illness
    • Controversies surrounding formal diagnostic criteria for psychiatric disorders
    • The framework of the diagnostic system
    • The structure of the chapters
    • A brief history of DSM-III
    • Psychiatry, science, and medicine
    • The DSM and health insurance
    • The guiding principles of DSM-III
    • The Feighner criteria
    • The DSM-III criteria
    • The success of DSM-III
    • Psychiatric disorders around the globe
    • Interpreting the prevalence of psychiatric disorders
    • The conservative approach
    • The dimensional approach
    • The network approach
    • Considering normal and abnormal responses to the environment
    • More lumping and less splitting
    • Considering the career of a diagnosis
    • Theory neutrality in practice
    • Mental disorders as essences
    • The production of unreliability
    • Diagnostic workarounds
    • Institutional pressures on diagnosis
    • The accuracy of diagnosis in primary-care settings
    • Using the DSM
    • Public beliefs about mental illness
    • How is information about diagnosis used in the clinical encounter?
    • Does the DSM create false epidemics?
    • The stigma of psychiatric disorders
    • Do labels matter for public beliefs?
    • Resisting and avoiding labels
    • Disease specificity and the public
    • The neglect of naturally occurring symptom profiles
    • The difficulties of revising the DSM for purposes of research
    • The DSM and the lexicon of disorders
    • Diagnosing versus treating disorders
    • The DSM creates new entities and not just new symptoms
    • Psychiatric disorders have strong semantic gravity
    • The use of psychiatric teams in fiction
    • Are there genes for mental illness?
    • Interpreting genetic influences
    • Are the effects of genes specific?
    • The neuroscience of psychiatric disorders
    • Is mental illness categorical?
    • Are major and minor disorders caused by different things?
    • Science and the DSM-5
    • The universe of validators
    • Science and judgment
    • Competition among scientific frameworks
    • The problem of consciousness
    • The appeal of the natural sciences
    • The inescapable importance of values
    • Summary
    • Conflict among science, clinicians, and the public
    • Moving forward
    • The diagnostic system in equilibrium
    • The last DSM.
    ISBN
    • 9780231178068 ((hardcover ; : alkaline paper))
    • 0231178069 ((hardcover ; : alkaline paper))
    LCCN
    2016056249
    OCLC
    965804813
    Statement on language in description
    Princeton University Library aims to describe library materials in a manner that is respectful to the individuals and communities who create, use, and are represented in the collections we manage. Read more...
    Other views
    Staff view